The new Los Angeles County Ethics Commission may nominate its final four members as soon as Friday, as the panel continues a public selection process that has been peppered with some very awkward moments.
They include the three sitting commissioners openly discussing whether to drop former Assembly member Wendy Carrillo from consideration based on an article they read, and Carrillo’s angry response.
But even the panel’s inaugural meeting on Oct. 16 had its cringe-worthy incidents, as in-person and call-in speakers used their short public comment time to tell Commissioners Michael Woo, Wilma Franco and Amanda Susskind why they, too, should be appointed to what ultimately will be a seven-member panel. The speakers appeared to believe that the comment period was the official public interview process for the four open seats.
It wasn’t. But the commission didn’t correct the speakers.
One applicant said she had been listening online and had not planned to call in, but called in to make a case for her appointment when she heard other applicants doing the same.
The Ethics Commission is mandated by Measure G, a 2024 charter reform ballot measure that redesigns county government. The commission details were hammered out earlier this year in a plan drawn up by a Governance Reform Task Force and adopted by the Board of Supervisors. Some of the recommendations required yet another charter amendment, which voters adopted on Nov. 3 as Measure E.
Woo, Franco and Susskind had, themselves, been part of the pool of more than 360 people who submitted their applications over the summer.
The Task Force nominated Woo. Board of Supervisors Chair Hilda Solis picked Franco, and Assessor Jeffrey Prang chose Susskind. All three were later confirmed by the supervisors.
The first three Ethics Commission members whittled the remaining applicants into a smaller pool of 16, who they interviewed in public meetings on Oct. 30 and Nov. 6. The commission is now set to consider eight finalists for the four slots, one of which is reserved for a member who lives in an unincorporated part of Los Angeles County.
The selection process has been conducted in public session under state open meeting laws. The point is ostensibly to make the process transparent; but the result has included some unnecessarily clunky and embarrassing situations, and has in several instances prevented, rather than accommodated, release of accurate information to the public.
That brings us back to Carrillo, who was one of the semi-finalists and was eligible, as a resident of East Los Angeles, for the unincorporated slot.
Carrillo’s public interview was scheduled for Nov. 6, but the commission began discussing her at the Oct. 30 meeting after Franco mentioned an online article that questioned Carrillo’s fitness to serve. Woo and Susskind also apparently read the article, but at the time none of the commissioners revealed where it ran, who wrote it or what it said.
Franco nevertheless asked whether “withdrawal” is possible, apparently referring to withdrawing Carrillo’s name from the list of semi-finalists.
“So now the question is,” Woo said, “should we reconsider the list of people who we’re going to spend half an hour with, or should we make some decision at this point, 50% of the way through the interviews, to change the list of interviewees. We're in an awkward situation.”
Woo said the commission’s rules do not permit members to conduct an executive session for what is, in essence, a personnel matter.
“This is not the way an ideal hiring process should go,” he said.
At Carrillo’s Nov. 6 public interview, she said she had been asked by commission staff to discuss the article, which ran in Citywatch. The online publication has carried numerous articles over the years that have been critical of Carrillo.
Carrillo brushed aside the personal attacks and said her concern instead “is that this commission established to uphold integrity, honesty, transparency, accountability would give weight to a political gossip blog and allegations without merit and without an independent investigation.”
She also noted that Franco was appointed by Solis, with whom Carrillo has had public and intense political disagreements, including over cityhood for East Los Angeles.
Franco is the executive director of SELA, the Southeast Los Angeles Collaborative. The organization credits Solis for helping to reinvigorate it in 2016.
“Given your professional relationship with Supervisor Solis,” Carrillo told Franco at the Ethics Commission meeting, “her involvement in establishing your organization and your organization's receipt of county resources, county funds, county projects, county contracts, I believe it is appropriate to ask whether those relationships have been disclosed and how impartiality is being safeguarded.”
Carrillo said she didn’t realize she’d have to organize a public support campaign to refute opponents and be a viable Ethics Commission applicant.
“That is the opposite of what this Ethics Commission should represent,” she said. “Independence cannot simply be a principle we discuss, it must be demonstrated through actions.”
Carrillo ultimately did not make the final list of contenders. Despite the cumbersome open meeting rules that are supposed to make the process transparent, the rankings that pared the list from 16 to eight were submitted by Woo, Franco and Susskind without public discussion, making it impossible to know whether she was omitted because of unvetted Citywatch allegations, her rivalry with Solis, her statement to Franco and the two other commissioners, or a desire to avoid controversy.
Or because she simply did not measure up to the other applicants.
The public process has misfired in other ways as well. At one point, Woo read aloud an email to the commission that asked why Measure E was on the ballot, given that there is already a county Ethics Commission (voters approved Measure E on Nov. 3).
He explained that Measure E’s purpose was to revive a 2020 alternatives to incarceration measure that had been inadvertently overwritten by a 2024 measure. That is correct, as far it goes, but Woo added:
“In other words, it has no substantive effect on the newly created Ethics Commission.”
That is not correct.
Measure E has two parts, the first of which provides the Ethics Commission with the independence that was supposed to come from Measure G, but didn’t, by finally permitting it to hire its own staff and lawyer. The commission to which Woo, Franco and Susskind were appointed was not independent of the elected officials they are supposed to scrutinize – until Measure E passed.
At the Oct. 30 commission meeting, county Assistant Executive Officer Shadi Kardan began to explain Measure E, but a county lawyer stopped her because the item wasn’t on the agenda.
Kardan then offered the public alternative ways to learn about the measure: Read your ballot. Check the Ethics Commission website. Check the Measure G website.
But there is nothing about Measure E on either website except links to the charter amendment language and cover letters, and a note under “FAQ” that says the measure sets the budget, structure and appointment process. It does not disclose that it makes the commission independent of the Board of Supervisors and other elected officials.
In fact the commission’s website incorrectly states that the new county executive, who is to take office in 2028, will appoint the ethics compliance officer. Instead, because of Measure E, the commission will make its own hiring decisions.
The eight finalists are Bert H. Deixler, Chun-Yen Chen, Eduardo Rodriguez, Gregory Gorman, Guy Primus, Jeffery Daar, Jennifer Farrell and Mieczyslaw Pawel Boduszynski.
On Friday, the three sitting commissioners are to select four nominees under the somewhat odd public process outlined in a county ordinance adopted earlier this year. Members of the public may weigh in on any of the candidates, which may prompt some to arrange the sort of public support campaign that Carrillo questioned at the previous meeting, or be targeted by public allegations like those leveled at Carrillo in the Citywatch article.
The process was quite different for selecting Woo, Franco and Susskind. Franco’s and Susskind’s names were put forward by elected officials. There was no public debate about their qualifications. Woo was selected from a pool of finalists after six hours of closed-session Governance Reform Task Force deliberations on Sept. 16.
In discussing Carrillo, Woo noted that for him, as for the other applicants, there was no traditional background check and therefore no ability to confirm the accuracy of any information he provided.
Kardan said nominations are expected to go to the Board of Supervisors for confirmation on Dec. 1 or Dec. 8.