L.A. County, maybe you’ve heard this story:
A young, liberal, hard-charging female county supervisor drives a charter overhaul. A conservative colleague criticizes her for directly benefitting from her proposed reforms. The measure creates a new county ethics commission. Details are left to an appointed task force but ultimately are in the hands of the Board of Supervisors.
But no, this isn’t L.A. County, Measure G, 2024 or Supervisor Lindsey Horvath.
It’s San Diego County, where on Nov. 3, voters adopted the charter overhaul driven by Supervisor Terra Lawson-Remer.
San Diego County election officials say results will be certified on or before Dec. 3.
Back in 2020, Lawson-Remer flipped the officially non-partisan San Diego County Board of Supervisors from a 36-year stretch of majority Republican rule to a Democratic majority. This year she led the charge for Measure A, which tinkers with the strong-county-manager system Republicans put in place in 1985.
Under the new governance format, the board will continue to appoint the county’s chief executive officer. But that person will now lose exclusive authority to hire and fire some top administrators and must share some of that power with the supervisors.
An implementation task force is reportedly to be headed by former San Diego City Manager Jack McGrory and Kyra Greene of the Center on Policy Initiatives, a politically progressive research and advocacy organization.
Lawson-Remer studied whether to include a Los Angeles-style elected county executive as part of her reform package but opted against it because she heard too little support for it.
Under Measure A, the ethics commission members will be appointed, and could be removed, by the Board of Supervisors. That puts them to some degree under the thumbs of the very people they are supposed to hold to account.
L.A.’s Measure G did the same thing. But the L.A. task force, which continues to do its work, argued for charter changes that would make the ethics commission independent of the board. The supervisors agreed and sent L.A. voters further reforms in the form of Measure E. It was approved on Nov. 3.
Los Angeles County election officials say the results will be certified by Nov. 27.
It’s not clear whether the San Diego County task force will recommend a further Measure E-type reform to make the ethics commission independent of elected officials, or whether the supervisors would send such a reform to voters.
Details of county governance may not seem like they’d be the basis of a riveting conversation, but hang on a minute. At issue are fundamental questions of American democracy and political power. What is the interplay, and what are the trade-offs, between governance formats that provide professional administration and oversight, and those that are directly accountable to the people? Can’t we have both? Do we want a government run by bureaucrats, or one run by politicians? Can’t we have neither? Which is the “good government” model?
The differing reform programs in San Diego and Los Angeles counties reflect differing theories about how we balance those often competing or conflicting goals in order to achieve the best representation and service.
With Measure G, L.A. is moving away completely from its often dysfunctional five-headed, and therefore headless, county government in favor of one with an elected executive clearly in charge, and with the supervisors providing oversight. The argument for the change is imposing checks and balances, and separation of powers – fundamental principles of the federal government, every U.S. state, 700 county governments and numerous cities.
But in California, most county and city governments operate on a corporate-style model, with the five supervisors hiring a chief executive to run the government. Under that format, supervisors keep their noses out of administrative business, except for hiring and firing the CEO.
With Measure A, San Diego County is moving away, slightly, from the corporate-style model.
It is interesting to note that Lawson-Remer touts checks and balances in her county’s government despite the absence of a federal or state-like separation of powers.
“What feels more democratic to you,” she asked during a Voice of San Diego podcast. “To be accountable to one person, the CAO, who’s not accountable to voters? Or to be accountable to a Board of Supervisors that is elected, that has checks and balances inherently, because we’re a diverse group, through a process that requires some kind of transparency and voter accountability and participation?”
There is a historical twist. In the 1990s, one of those professional CAOs who was not accountable to voters left San Diego County to become CAO of Los Angeles County.
David E. Janssen was highly regarded in both positions, but the job was not the same. In San Diego County, he ran the government and supervisors were required by law to keep their noses out of administration. In L.A., the supervisors ran the county directly – or at least Janssen allowed them to believe they did, while he tried to direct departments whose leaders he did not hire and could not fire.
When he announced his retirement in 2006, the supervisors couldn’t find any qualified person who wanted to succeed him. No one wanted to be saddled with the responsibility to run the nation’s largest county while lacking the authority to actually do the job.
Janssen urged the board to try the San Diego model: Hire an empowered CEO and provide oversight but not interfere in administration. The supervisors reluctantly agreed, but simply could not stop trying to run the county themselves. They dropped the pretense of an empowered San Diego-style CEO less than a decade later.
Having tried and failed to use the empowered administrator model, L.A. County instead adopted Measure G to provide an independently elected county executive beginning in 2028.
Predictably, there is pushback, especially from people with a stake in the old way the county operated, with powerful and largely unaccountable supervisors.
So we have an experiment afoot – the old, corporate (or professional, or bureaucracy-led) San Diego County model; the new hybrid San Diego model with some powers transferred back to the supervisors; the old L.A. (or politician-led, or leaderless) model; or the new L.A. (even more political, or politically accountable) model. Which format provides the most responsive government, the most equity, the most liberty, the most value per tax dollar, the most prevention and protection from natural disaster, the least fraud and waste? Which model attracts the most talent, rewards the best innovation, supports the highest quality of life? Do we prefer a government we can control, if it means devoting more of our daily attention to it, or one that runs on autopilot and requires little from us but our votes on election day? How will we know the answers, and how will we respond when we do?
States, it is said, are laboratories of democracy. In 2026, though, the lab work has become focused on two of the nation’s largest counties. Let the experiments commence.
Previously: Are San Diego County’s reforms similar to L.A.’s? Or the polar opposite?